Jamaican Scotch Bonnet Pepper Sauce
This Jamaican recipe cooks Scotch bonnet peppers with carrot, cho cho, onion, garlic, ginger, allspice and vinegar, then blends and strains the mixture.
Caribbean browning (burnt-sugar seasoning)
Browning sauce · Browning · Burnt sugar browning · Jamaican browning sauce
Caribbean browning is a dark liquid of deeply caramelised sugar, used in small amounts for colour and a smoky, bitter-sweet flavour in stews and black cake.
Colour before flavour
Caribbean browning is a dark liquid made from sugar cooked past golden caramel until it is nearly black. It is not a sweet sauce for pouring over food. A few spoonfuls go into a pot of stew, where it gives the gravy its deep brown colour and a smoky, slightly bitter, molasses-like note.
It is also used in black cake and in savoury dishes such as oxtail, stew chicken, stew beef and peas and rice. In those dishes the flavour is secondary; the cook is buying a colour and a faint bitterness that a plain sugar syrup does not give.
Sources for this section
Burnt sugar as a technique
Browning is a controlled caramelisation, and the control is the whole task. Sugar melts, turns golden, then amber, then brown, and each stage has a different colour and taste. The home recipe advises low and slow heat and warns that going past dark brown turns the liquid bitter. The stop point is the choice of the cook: medium amber for a light colour, darker for more colour.
Water is added once the caramel has cooled slightly, because hot caramel can splatter when water meets it. The mixture is then thinned to a pourable liquid. A small amount of lemon juice or vinegar is sometimes added to stop the sugar from crystallising.
Sources for this section
Home and commercial browning
Commercial browning in the Caribbean is sometimes a caramel colour in water, as one Trinidadian brand is described, and the home version is a different product made from sugar. The two are used for the same job, and home cooks treat the homemade bottle as a fresher and more controllable choice.
A home bottle is kept cold. The recipe gives three months refrigerated and asks the cook to shake it if it separates. That figure comes from a recipe blog, not from testing, and the sauce should be made in small batches.
Sources for this section
Open questions
The sources do not establish a dated origin in Jamaica or Trinidad, do not give a tested shelf life, and differ on the heat used. The browning in black cake and stew is a regional habit, and its exact history is undocumented here.
Sources for this section
History
A Jamaican recipe blog says Caribbean cooks have used caramelised sugar since the colonial era, and that burnt sugar added colour and flavour. That claim cites no source. A Caribbean food writer describes the sauce as a family kitchen practice learned from a father, not as a documented history. Commercial brands in Trinidad and Jamaica are named as ready-made options.
Ingredients
Scaling: source batch only
SugarCane sugar, white or light brown.
237 mL1 cup as recorded
Per the home recipe.Water (optional)Added to dissolve the sugar, and later to thin the caramel.
118 mL½ cup as recorded
Optional step in the recipe.Lemon juice (optional)
2.5 mL½ tsp as recorded
Or vinegar; added to prevent crystallisation.Salt (optional)
A pinch, optional.
Method
Risks and precautions · Standard risk
Hot caramel
Adding water to hot caramel can cause it to splatter.
Hazard sourceOvercooked sugar
Sugar that goes past dark brown burns and tastes bitter; the recipe says to start a fresh batch.
Hazard sourceAdd water slowly to the hot caramel
Control sourceRefrigerate the bottled browning; the home recipe gives three months
Control sourceWatch the sugar closely. Burnt sugar is bitter and cannot be fixed by adding more sugar or water.
- Use a heavy-bottomed saucepan, a wooden spoon and a heatproof bottle for storage.
- Heat the sugar over medium heat, stirring occasionally, until it melts and turns golden. Some versions add a little water to help the sugar melt.
- Keep heating until the caramel reaches a dark amber or brown. Stop at medium amber for a lighter colour, or continue for a darker one.
- Stir in the optional half teaspoon of lemon juice or vinegar to stabilise the caramel for one to two minutes.
- Remove from the heat and let it cool slightly.
- Add the water slowly, as it may sizzle, and stir until smooth.
- Bottle when cool, seal, and refrigerate. Shake before use if the liquid separates.
Places
Jamaica
Documented preparation · Country evidenceA Jamaican home and commercial browning. The sources give a Jamaican origin as a claim, not a dated record.
Trinidad and Tobago
Documented use · Country evidenceA commercial browning there is named as a caramel colour and water product.
Related
More from Jamaica
Wet jerk seasoning
A Jamaican wet jerk paste of ground allspice, Scotch bonnet pepper, thyme, scallion, garlic, ginger and nutmeg, loosened with soy sauce, oil, vinegar and lime, used to marinate meat, fish or tofu before cooking.
Ackee and saltfish
Jamaica's best-known dish: salt-cured cod desalted and flaked, then folded through ackee arils with onion, tomato, sweet pepper, thyme and Scotch bonnet.
Bammy finished with coconut milk
A serving method for approved, prepared bammy rounds: soak them in coconut milk and refry until golden. It does not process raw cassava.
Coco bread (Immaculate Bites version)
Jamaican-style folded rolls made from sweet coconut-milk yeast dough and brushed with butter.
Hard dough bread
Jamaican hard dough bread is a firm, close-crumbed yeasted wheat loaf with a thicker crust and a soft, chewy interior. Roll the dough tightly and bake it in a loaf tin.
Jamaican Easter spice bun
A Jamaican Easter loaf made from a dark, sweet batter of stout, dried fruit and warm spices. This version uses baking powder and a loaf pan; yeast-raised variations are separate preparations.
Related in the family
Ajvar
Ajvar is a cooked Balkan pepper preserve built around roasted red peppers, peeled, drained, ground and slowly fried with oil and seasoning. Leskovac’s protected version is a pepper specialty; regional versions vary.
Amlou
Amlou is a nutty, lightly sweet Moroccan spread of roasted almonds, culinary argan oil and honey. The almonds are ground first, then loosened with oil and sweetened; the balance can range from a thick spread to a dip.
Apple sauce for goose and pork
Apple sauce for goose and pork is a plain English accompaniment: cooked apples pulped with water, then sweetened with sugar and finished with a little butter.
Bagna cauda
A warm dip of garlic, anchovy and olive oil, often enriched with butter, that Piedmont serves over a flame with raw and cooked vegetables and bread.
Banana ketchup in a Filipino-inspired direction
A sweet-hot table sauce of ripe banana simmered with vinegar, sugar, onion, garlic and fresh chilli, in the manner of Philippine banana ketchup. An untested development batch of about 500 g.
Bazhe (walnut sauce base)
A Georgian walnut sauce of ground walnuts, garlic, vinegar and spices, thinned with water or broth. It is served with poultry, vegetables and bread, and is the sauce of the dish satsivi.
Butterscotch sauce
A pourable dessert sauce of brown sugar, butter and cream, with a little corn syrup and salt. It is the sauce form of the butterscotch confection and is made without water, unlike caramel.
Byzantine murrī
Byzantine murrī is a cooked imitation of murrī from the medieval Arabic repertoire, made from scorched honey, toasted bread, walnuts, quince, carob and spices rather than from a long grain fermentation.
Community
No community contributions have been published for this entry yet.
Share what you made
Sign in to contribute. Published comments and photos are free to read.
Sources
Jerk TavernMethod · Safety · History
Homemade Browning Sauce Recipe (2 Ingredients)1 cup cane sugar, 1/2 cup water, 1/2 tsp vinegar or lemon juice; medium heat; add water to hot caramel slowly; refrigerate up to 3 months; bitter if past dark brown; colonial-era claim (uncited)
Cited in: Colour before flavour; Burnt sugar as a technique; Home and commercial browning; Open questions
Uncommon CaribbeanHistory · Culinary use · Variants
Browning Sauce Makes Everything Better, EasilyBrowning used in oxtail stew, peas and rice, stew chicken, stew beef and black cake; a Trinidad and Tobago commercial browning described as caramel colour and water; author's family account
Cited in: Colour before flavour; Home and commercial browning; Open questions