← Recipes

Georgian England vinegar gherkins

vinegar gherkins · Georgian gherkins · pickled gerkins

Loading ratings…

Small cucumbers under hot spiced vinegar, the pickle Georgian cooks greened in copper pans. This version uses the tested NCHFP fresh-pack dill method, glass and stainless steel, and accepts the olive colour a safe jar turns.

Clear glass jar of whole vinegar gherkins with dill on warm ivory linen.

What this pickle is

Gherkins are small cucumbers, picked young and firm. In Georgian England they were the commonest vinegar pickle in the store cupboard, eaten with cold meat, cheese and bread. The vinegar does the preserving. There is no long lactic ferment.

The method here is the tested Quick fresh-pack dill pickle from the US National Center for Home Food Preservation, with metric equivalents added. Fermentea already carries that batch as Quick fresh-pack dill pickles. This page adds the history of the English gherkin, and the reason it no longer comes out of the jar bright green.

If you want a salt-brine pickle that sours by fermentation, use Fermented dill pickles instead. The note further down explains how the two differ. For small whole gherkins in a sweet spiced vinegar syrup, Sweet gherkin pickles is a separate tested method that takes four days.

Sources for this section

The batch at a glance

About 8 lb (3.6 kg) of 3- to 5-inch (7.5–12.5 cm) pickling cucumbers makes 7 to 9 pint jars. A US pint is about 475 ml and a quart about 950 ml.

The salt and spice are measured by US volume, as the recipe was tested. Use 3/4 cup (180 ml) of canning salt for the overnight soak and 1/2 cup (120 ml) for the brine. Pickling salt varies in density between brands, so stick with these measures and avoid flake salt.

The brine is 1½ quarts (1.4 litres) of 5% vinegar, 2 quarts (1.9 litres) of water, the salt and 1/4 cup (60 ml) of sugar, boiled with 2 tbsp of whole pickling spice in a cloth bag. Each pint jar gets 1 tsp mustard seed and 1½ heads of dill.

Time: 12 hours for the soak, about an hour and a half of work, then a day for the jars to cool and seal.

For a smaller batch, halve every quantity: 4 lb (1.8 kg) of cucumbers fills about 4 pints. Keep the ratios exact and the process times the same, because the times depend on jar size and elevation, not on how many jars are in the canner.

Sources for this section

Choosing cucumbers, salt and vinegar

Use firm pickling cucumbers or true gherkins, picked as recently as you can get them. Slicing cucumbers go soft. Trim 1/16 inch (1.5 mm) from the blossom end of each one. The blossom end can carry an enzyme that softens pickles in the jar.

Use canning or pickling salt. Table salt with anti-caking agents clouds the brine and can leave a white sediment, and iodised salt can darken the pickles.

Use vinegar labelled 5% acidity, white distilled or cider. Do not dilute it or use homemade vinegar of unknown strength. For context, the vinegar Hassall found in London shop pickles in the 1850s was between 1.48 and 2.91 per cent acetic acid.

Sources for this section

Pans and jars

Every surface the vinegar touches should be glass, stainless steel, unchipped enamelware, stoneware or food-grade plastic. NCHFP lists brass, iron, copper and zinc utensils as a cause of dark pickles and says that pickles made with brass, copper or zinc should not be used. The FDA Food Code bars copper and copper alloys from contact with foods below pH 6, and gives vinegar as its example.

That excludes the old copper preserving pan, a brass jam pan, bronze or bell-metal, and galvanised buckets for the soak. Use a stainless or enamelled pan for the brine.

You also need canning jars with new lids, a boiling-water canner or a deep pot with a rack, a jar lifter and a thermometer if you use the low-temperature treatment. Accum warned in 1820 against storing pickles in cream-coloured glazed earthenware, whose lead glaze the vinegar dissolved. Modern canning jars avoid the problem.

Sources for this section

Why the steps run in this order

The 12-hour soak in salt water comes first, as tested, and seasons the cucumbers before the vinegar goes on. Drain it off; it is not used again.

The brine goes on boiling. Hot liquid drives air out of the jar and starts the heating that the canner finishes. The 1/2 inch (1.25 cm) of headspace leaves room for the seal to form.

Dill heads and dill seed are interchangeable in this recipe: 1½ heads or 1½ tsp of seed per pint. Whole spices keep the brine clear. Ground spices can darken the pickles.

Process time rises with elevation because water boils at a lower temperature higher up. Find your kitchen's elevation before you start.

The low-temperature option gives a firmer pickle but needs care. Start the jars in water at 120–140 °F (49–60 °C), top up with hot water to 1 inch above the lids, and hold 180–185 °F (82–85 °C) for 30 minutes. Above 185 °F (85 °C) the pickles soften for no gain in safety. Below 180 °F (82 °C) they are not adequately treated.

Sources for this section

What colour to expect

The jars will turn olive within days, sometimes yellow at the ends. That is what a safe vinegar pickle looks like.

Chlorophyll holds a magnesium ion at its centre. Acid and heat push the magnesium out, and the pigment becomes pheophytin, which is olive-brown. Copper can take the empty place and make a bright green that survives acid and heat. Georgian cooks knew the bright result without knowing the chemistry, and boiled their vinegar in copper to get it.

The pickle trade described the copper method plainly. In 1855 Thomas Blackwell, of Crosse & Blackwell, told a parliamentary committee that for thirty-five years his firm had boiled pickle vinegar in copper and poured it back over the vegetables several times. "The first time that was done it turned yellow, the next time green." After The Lancet published Hassall's analyses, the firm moved to glass-lined iron pans and boiled the vinegar only once in its remaining copper vessels. Its pickles came out brown.

Arthur Hill Hassall stated the rule in 1876. Pickles that housekeepers made at home were "usually of a yellow colour rather than green". Whenever shop pickles were "of a decided green, they will almost always be found to contain copper; but when they are yellowish or brownish-green, copper is never present."

Do not add alum, copper salts or anything else to keep the colour. White distilled vinegar keeps the jar a little paler than cider vinegar. Store sealed jars in the dark, because light fades them further.

Sources for this section

How the Georgian kitchen did it

This section is history. Read it; do not cook from it.

Hannah Glasse's 1758 gherkins went into a brine with "as much Salt as will make it bear an Egg", then into a stone jar. Her pickle was three quarts of vinegar to one of spring water, with nutmeg, cloves, mace, pepper and ginger, boiled "in a Bell-metal or Copper Pot" and poured over boiling hot, then drained, reboiled and poured over again on later days. Each boiling took up more copper.

Elizabeth Raffald, writing in 1769, called greening in brass "poison to a great degree". Her pickled cucumbers sat in strong salt and water for nine or ten days "till they are quite yellow", stirred twice a day "or they will scum over and grow soft". She then poured boiling water over them under vine leaves, four or five times, until they looked green again. They finished in white wine vinegar boiled for five minutes with mace, cloves, ginger, black pepper and salt, and were tied down with a bladder.

Eliza Acton in 1845 poured boiling brine over gherkins in a stone jar, laid them under bay leaves the next day, and covered them with boiling vinegar spiced with ginger, peppercorns and mace. She noted the "brilliant and poisonous green" a brass skillet gave and chose the duller colour. Isabella Beeton's pickled gherkins of 1861 followed the same plan, with vine leaves, a night by the fire and "in a month or two, they will be fit for use."

Shop pickles kept the copper. When Hassall bought pickles from London grocers, oilmen and pickle makers in the early 1850s, every one of the sixteen he tested for copper contained it, and the green gherkins and beans held the most. He told shoppers to stand a polished iron wire in the vinegar for a few hours: copper would plate out on the iron.

None of these is a tested shelf-stable process, and the vinegar strength in any of them is unknown. Their spice mixes are worth borrowing for flavour. Tie a little sliced ginger, black peppercorns and a blade of mace into the spice bag in place of part of the pickling spice, keeping the total about the same. Do not change the vinegar, salt or water.

Sources for this section

If you want a fermented gherkin

Raffald's nine-day brine began the change a salt ferment makes. The cucumbers turned yellow, and a scum formed on the surface unless she stirred them, the same surface growth anyone who ferments in brine will recognise. She then switched to vinegar for keeping.

A fully fermented cucumber is a different recipe with its own salt, temperature and timing. Fermentea's Fermented dill pickles follows the NCHFP method, which cures for about three weeks. NCHFP also describes refrigerator dills, fermented for about a week. As fermented pickles cure, their colour and flavour change and their acidity rises, so a short ferment stays greener than a long one.

Do not combine the two methods. A part-fermented cucumber packed with this page's brine and process times has not been tested. Choose one recipe and follow it all the way through.

Sources for this section

When it goes wrong

Soft or slippery pickles: weak vinegar, cucumbers not covered by brine, a skipped process, mouldy spices or blossom ends left on. If there is any sign of spoilage, do not eat them.

Shrivelled pickles: brine or vinegar stronger than the recipe, or over-processing. Bitter pickles: spices boiled too long, or a salt substitute.

Dark pickles: hard water, ground spices, spices left in the jar, iodised salt, or brass, iron, copper or zinc utensils. If a reactive metal was used, discard the batch.

Faded pickles: too much light in storage, or poor cucumbers. Bulging lids, spurting liquid, mould inside the jar or an off smell mean the jar goes in the bin without tasting.

Sources for this section

Serving and storage

Store sealed jars cool, dark and dry. Once a jar is open, keep it in the fridge with the cucumbers under the brine.

Serve with cold meat, a ploughman's plate of cheese and bread, chopped into tartare sauce or potato salad, or sliced on a sandwich.

Sources for this section

History

Hannah Glasse's 1758 gherkins were brined until the salt would float an egg, then scalded three times with spiced vinegar boiled "in a Bell-metal or Copper Pot". Elizabeth Raffald's 1769 book warned that greening in brass is "poison to a great degree", soaked cucumbers in brine until yellow and greened them with boiling water and vine leaves. Eliza Acton in 1845 and Isabella Beeton in 1861 used stone jars and boiling spiced vinegar with no metal pan. Fredrick Accum in 1820 and Arthur Hill Hassall in the 1850s documented copper-greened shop pickles. The modern method is the separate NCHFP tested fresh-pack.

Ingredients

Yield 8 pints · Scaling: do not change the vinegar to water ratio or the process times when scaling; follow nchfp elevation bands.

Pickling cucumbersUse 3- to 5-inch pickling cucumbers or smaller gherkins; wash; cut a 1/16-inch blossom-end slice and leave 1/4-inch stem.
3.63 kg8 lb as recorded
About 3.6 kg; 7.5–12.5 cm long; trim 1.5 mm from the blossom end, leave 6 mm stem.
WaterFor the overnight salt soak.
7.57 L2 gal as recorded
About 7.6 litres, for the soak.
Canning or pickling saltUse 3/4 cup in the soak and 1/2 cup in the brine, as directed in the steps.
296 mL1¼ cup as recorded
US cups by volume as tested: 180 ml for the soak plus 120 ml for the brine.
Vinegar, 5% acidityWhite distilled or cider vinegar labelled 5% acidity.
1.42 L1½ qt as recorded
About 1.4 litres.
59 mL¼ cup as recorded
60 ml.
WaterFor the pickling brine.
1.89 L2 qt as recorded
About 1.9 litres, for the brine.
Whole mixed pickling spiceTie in a clean white cloth for the brine.
30 mL2 tbsp as recorded
30 ml.
Whole mustard seed1 tsp per pint jar.
44 mL3 tbsp as recorded
About 45 ml in all.
Fresh dill headsAbout 1.5 heads per pint jar; or use 4.5 tbsp dill seed instead.
14
Or 4½ tbsp (about 70 ml) dill seed, 1½ tsp per pint jar.

Method

Risks and precautions · High risk
Copper, brass or zinc contact with vinegar

Vinegar dissolves copper from copper and copper-alloy pans. Eighteenth- and nineteenth-century pickles were greened this way, and Hassall found copper in every shop pickle he tested in the 1850s. The FDA Food Code bars copper and copper alloys from contact with foods below pH 6, and NCHFP says not to use pickles made with brass, copper or zinc utensils.

Hazard source
Insufficient acid or heat processing

Cucumbers are a low-acid vegetable made safe on the shelf by the tested vinegar ratio and the canner process. Weak vinegar, changed proportions or a shortened process can leave the jar under-acidified or under-processed.

Hazard source
Copper salts or verdigris as colourants

Powdered verdigris and copper sulphate were used to force a bright green. They are poisons, not ingredients.

Hazard source

Use glass, stainless steel, unchipped enamelware, stoneware or food-grade plastic for every step; never copper, brass, bronze, zinc or iron.

Control source

Use the NCHFP formula exactly, with vinegar labelled 5% acidity and the process time for your jar size and elevation.

Control source

If using low-temperature pasteurisation, keep the water at 180–185 °F (82–85 °C) for the full 30 minutes, checked with a thermometer.

Control source

Never add copper salts, verdigris, coins or any metal greening agent.

Control source

Never green pickles with copper. A bright emerald pickle from a copper or brass pan is contaminated; discard it untasted.

Colour, smell and firmness do not prove a home-canned pickle is safe. Follow the tested formula and check the seals.

  1. Wash the cucumbers. Cut a 1/16-inch (1.5 mm) slice off each blossom end and discard it. Leave 1/4 inch (6 mm) of stem attached.
  2. Dissolve 3/4 cup (180 ml) canning or pickling salt in 2 gallons (7.6 litres) of water in a glass, stainless steel or food-grade plastic container. Pour over the cucumbers and leave them for 12 hours. Drain.
  3. In a stainless steel or enamelled pan, combine 1½ quarts (1.4 litres) of 5% vinegar, 1/2 cup (120 ml) salt, 1/4 cup (60 ml) sugar and 2 quarts (1.9 litres) of water. Add the pickling spice tied in a clean white cloth. Heat to boiling. Never use a copper, brass, bronze or zinc pan.
  4. Fill clean pint jars with cucumbers. Add 1 tsp mustard seed and 1½ heads fresh dill (or 1½ tsp dill seed) to each pint.
  5. Cover with the boiling pickling solution, leaving 1/2 inch (1.25 cm) headspace. Remove air bubbles, wipe the rims and fit the lids.
  6. Process in a boiling-water canner. Pints: 10 minutes at 0–1,000 ft (0–305 m), 15 minutes at 1,001–6,000 ft (306–1,830 m), 20 minutes above 6,000 ft. Quarts: 15, 20 or 25 minutes on the same bands. Or use the low-temperature pasteurisation treatment: water held at 180–185 °F (82–85 °C) for 30 minutes, checked with a thermometer throughout.
  7. Cool the jars undisturbed for 12–24 hours. Check the seals. Store sealed jars somewhere cool, dark and dry. Refrigerate any jar that did not seal and eat it first.

Conditions

Yield8 pints
Active time90 min

Places

England

Historical attestation · Country evidence

Attested in English cookery books from Glasse (1758) to Beeton (1861) and in Accum's and Hassall's adulteration reports.

Related

Community

No community contributions have been published for this entry yet.

Share what you made

Sign in to contribute. Published comments and photos are free to read.

Sources